Skip to main content

Make a Payment

Make a Payment - Ohio Mutual Insurance Group

Thank you for choosing Ohio Mutual Insurance Group. You have several convenient options from which to choose, in order to make paying your bill as easy as possible.

Before initiating a payment, please have the following information ready:

  • Account Number (located on your current billing statement)
    * Please note that your account number must be provided with any option to insure accurate posting of your payment.
  • Credit or debit card number & expiration date (mm/yyyy)
  • Zip code where the card statement is mailed
  • Routing and checking account numbers (if paying electronically)
  • Dollar amount you wish to pay

Pay Online Now

You can conveniently pay your bill online using your Visa, MasterCard, Discover, ATM card check card or checking or savings account.

As an Ohio Mutual policyholder, you can conveniently pay your bill online - with no additional fees - using our convenient 360access® web portal, which you can access by clicking the button below.



Set up automatic payments using your credit card, checking account, or savings account, and have the peace of mind knowing that your insurance payments are on-time, every time! This is another value-added service made possible through our self-service 360access® web portal. Sign up today!


Automatic Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)

Provide the completed form to your local agent, and they can complete arrangements to have your premium payments electronically deducted from your bank account.

  • Convenient and secure!
  • No late payments!
  • No postage!
  • No additional fees!

Pay By Phone

Call 877-699-7364 to pay using your Visa, MasterCard, Discover, ATM card, credit card, or checking or savings account.  There is no fee for using this service.


Pay By Mail

Send check or money order with the remittance portion of your current billing statement. There is no fee for this payment option. Mail payments to the following address:

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group
P.O. Box 111
Bucyrus, Ohio 44820